Can you say that you read a book if you listened to somebody else read the book?
I have addressed this question in the past in this space, always in the affirmative, but I bring it up again in response to a recent front-page article in The Wall Street Journal. Jeffrey A. Trachtenberg writes about Brittany Lowry, a 34-year-old Canadian woman who claims to have read 80 books in 2024, yet she didn't actually read a word. She listened to all these books while doing something else.
So, did she read the books or not?
There are arguments on both sides of this question. If listening counts as reading, then an illiterate man could rightly claim to have read War and Peace. Yet at the same time, this man who can't actually read, but listened to the novel, knows it much better than a person who can read but has never read that particular book.
Could you say that you read a speech after listening to that speech or that you read a friend's comments after engaging in a face-to-face conversation? No, each of these would be ridiculous. Yet the phrase "reading a book" suggests knowing the book, knowing the story if it's fiction, knowing the subject matter if it's nonfiction. One can do those just as well by listening as by actually reading. (But not by watching a movie based on that book, I would argue.) In fact, some individuals with reading disabilities have gotten college degrees by having other people read the textbooks to them. Did they cheat? I don't think so.
I think it comes down to what you consider most important in the phrase "reading a book," the word reading or the word book. Reading suggests a specific act, transforming images into meaningful words. A book, however, consists of the words themselves and what they mean, not on the page but in one's mind. And this can happen by sight, by sound or, in the case of the blind, by touch.
A contributor to Oh Reader magazine avoids this debate altogether with the following sentence: "Between print and audio, I experienced seven to nine books per month ..." That's clever, but then I can experience a book by moving it from one shelf to another.
If Brittany Lowry had had to sit down and read her books page by page, chances are she would have read very few of those 80, if any at all. I, for one, am willing to give her credit for reading all 80. Of course, I also want credit for reading countless books over the years that I only listened to while driving my car.
Next time I will focus on the advantages and disadvantages of both kinds of reading.