Monday, November 16, 2026

Together, yet alone

Every novel is, in the end, a social experience as well as an experience of solitude.
Jane Smiley, 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel

Reading is almost always a solitary experience. True, one person can read to another or even to a roomful of people. You can discuss a book with someone else after you have read it, or even while you are reading it. Even so, reading a book normally involves just the reader with the book itself. Often there is no one else in the room.

Jane Smiley
Yet Jane Smiley describes reading a novel as a social experience, as well. She describes reading a long novel as "akin to a long train ride with a stranger, sometimes more demanding and uncongenial than the reader is prepared for."

When one reads a novel, one is thrust into a temporary relationship with new people who it may or may not be a pleasure to be with and into situations that may or may not be comfortable. As with conversing with a stranger on a train, one must simply see where it leads.

Smiley makes these comments while discussing Fyodor Dostoevsky, but her comments ring true for any author. Writers put readers not just in new situations with characters one might never meet in real life, they also put readers into the minds of these characters. The better the novelist  and the better the novel, the more one experiences community with other people while, at the same time being very much alone.

No comments:

Post a Comment